make !nominate vip-only again

Status
Not open for further replies.
Wait so basically you opened a thread to make the basic general command of nominations being a VIP feature?
 
Wait so basically you opened a thread to make the basic general command of nominations being a VIP feature?
We had that for quite some time where during primetime in the evening only VIPs could nominate.
 
  • Like
Reactions: vinto
As far as I know it was to make VIP more attractive again, no (cause money reasons)? Don't see that being the case anymore.

I don't personally see a reason to implement this again. It's not like being a VIP grants people the ability to nominate the maps you personally like. I'd say it's pretty even between established players/vips/unknown players to fill the nomlist with less good maps.

A bigger problem is how some people on purpose nominate a bad map they themselves won't vote for because their favorite map is already nominated, to ensure more people will vote their favorite map.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Luke and 541m4n
Why don't we set a maxplayer to some maps instead, or have them unavailable during specific hours. That will solve the problem of having certain bad/casual maps being played on a full server/during prime time and also we won't have to make !nominate vip again, which i highly disagree with.
 
Your thread actually gave me an idea. I pm'd neon & dogan (even tho he has no access anymore) about it. Dogan said it's a possible idea and told me to post it here and perhaps @jenz could make a vote about it.

------
I propose a change change how map nominations work. Instead of requiring one person to nominate one map, it would require multiple people to nominate one map (similar to the voteleader plugin where a number of people have to vote for a person to be come leader). This can be approached in two ways:

- Either it could be in such a way where the most nominated maps enter the nomlist (edit: see neon's comment below)
- OR different maps could have different requirements based on the map. For example mako would require 3 people to "nominate" it to add the map to the nomlist or maybe minas would require 5 nominations to add it to the nomlist. ([sm] William! :D has nominated ze_FFVII_Mako_Reactor_v5_3 (1/5))

The idea behind this is to more accurately try to represent what people wish to play on the server and it would enable more people to contribute to the map voting rather than the fastest 5 people.
 
Last edited:
Your thread actually gave me an idea. I pm'd neon & dogan (even tho he has no access anymore) about it. Dogan said it's a possible idea and told me to post it here and perhaps @jenz could make a vote about it.

------
I propose a change change how map nominations work. Instead of requiring one person to nominate one map, it would require multiple people to nominate one map (similar to the voteleader plugin where a number of people have to vote for a person to be come leader). This can be approached in two ways:

- Either it could be in such a way where the most nominated maps enter the nomlist (edit: see neon's comment below)
- OR different maps could have different requirements based on the map. For example mako would require 3 people to "nominate" it to add the map to the nomlist or maybe minas would require 5 nominations to add it to the nomlist. ([sm] William! :D has nominated ze_FFVII_Mako_Reactor_v5_3 (1/5))

The idea behind this is to more accurately try to represent what people wish to play on the server and it would enable more people to contribute to the map voting rather than the fastest 5 people.


upload_2021-2-12_13-41-12.png
 
Paranoid removal vote when? :P
In the future, or make a plugin where you can choose once in a week what map should get removed from the nomlist.
Like a command that you can only use once a week to remove one map that you think its not good now to play in the nomlist. idk if thats possible and if it would be too annoying.
 
so there won't be any crappy nomlists cuz holy shit every time I join the server I see the exact same players nominating boatescape/atix panic/rocket escape/onahole etc.
then make it like, you can nominate only once per day as normal player, 4 - 5 times a day as a vip and as a admin infinite.
 
As far as I know it was to make VIP more attractive again, no (cause money reasons)? Don't see that being the case anymore.

I don't personally see a reason to implement this again. It's not like being a VIP grants people the ability to nominate the maps you personally like. I'd say it's pretty even between established players/vips/unknown players to fill the nomlist with less good maps.

A bigger problem is how some people on purpose nominate a bad map they themselves won't vote for because their favorite map is already nominated, to ensure more people will vote their favorite map.
Yeah i realised that.
 
Is this possible(?): If a map you nominated wins, you're not allowed to nominate the same map for a week (maybe too harsh, 3-4 days probably)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.