Malala ban appeal

Status
Not open for further replies.

Malala

Renowned User
Feb 23, 2018
121
26
In-Game Name: Malala
Steam ID: STEAM_0:1:163976933
Banned by: u egg
Server: Zombie Escape
Reason: Knifing zombie forward

It was hold em mode on Mountain Escape, which is an incredibly difficult mode due to the high aa that it is basically never won

The admin also called a slay vote which had 64% so I assumed the round was over anyways, so I knifed a zombie, who using the high AA strafed and killed the team.

Checking the demo it does look like the direction I knifed him was forward but I have high ping so my POV is quite different from the demo, if you check the Zombie I knifed he is flying away at first.
E353BAED0172C24D6F5030EB670D470EFFE8B327

And starts to strafe
ACCF7952D3132394FB62E0C171F406BC87CC05FB

9BF41CFACBD415811198C24AF5258E5DC336C068


I probably shouldn't have knifed him as it was obvious this could've happened but given that I assumed we were slaying due to a 64% slay vote I feel a month long ban is too harsh.
 
  • Like
Reactions: u egg
I can confirm the voteslay (was ghostie's). In my opinion it can indeed by confusing to see a 64% vote, most votes don't need 65%.
On that point, to explain my side, I did not take the voteslay into account as so much shit was happening in the chat (we were talking about the knife in admin chat, thus why I remained silent for the following round besides a lenny or two) I just couldn't process everything.

High AA makes the knifing game like a lottery sometimes, one slight miscalculation and there goes the team accidentally. It happened to me, I know since then I should retain from knifing in high-risks low-rewards moments. You should really be careful in those situations. The knife here was really plain stupid and unnecessary.

One thing I kinda dislike about this is that not a single sorry was said. I mean, even if accidental you kinda ruined a round for all the CTs.

If we mix these elements together we have a confusing situation on a 'shitmap' ;
Should the punishment stay? Well the rules were broken (no knife forward under any circumstance).
Should the punishment be 1-month long? Taking a second look with the elements brought here explains some whys. Me, I'd reduce. But it's not me who decides.

These are just my personnal opinions and do not reflect the opinions of the Global Admins in anyways, I'm just providing my input for this ban in particular.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Malala
Since dogan made a new plugin called knifeban we will go with that.
What it does is it blocks you from knifing any zombies at all and that knifeban will stay for 2 months.
However the ban itself has been lifted and you can play again.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.